i
Compared to What? Establishing Environmental Baselines for Tornado Warning Skill
-
2021
Source: Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 102(4), E738-E747.
[PDF-1.74 MB]
Details:
-
Journal Title:Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society
-
Personal Author:
-
NOAA Program & Office:
-
Description:In any discussion of forecast evaluation, it is tempting to fall back on statements reflecting unverified assumptions: “this tornado warning had lower skill because the underlying meteorology reflected a complicated or atypical scenario,” or “that forecast performed worse than we would have expected given the straightforward setup.” These statements of what is and is not a reasonable expectation for warning skill are particularly relevant as the meteorological community’s focus has begun to emphasize non-classic storm environments (e.g., tornadoes spawned by quasi-linear convective systems). In this paper, we build a proof-of-concept methodology to quantify the effect of the near-storm environment on tornado warning skill, and we then test these methods on a 15-yr dataset composed of tens of thousands of tornado events and warnings over the contiguous United States. Our findings include that significant tornadoes rated (E)F2+ have a higher probability of detection (POD) than expected based on their near-storm environments, that nocturnal tornadoes have both worse POD and false alarm ratio (FAR) than even their marginal near-storm environments would suggest, and that tornadoes occurring during the summer months also show worse POD and FAR than their environment-based expectation. Quantifying these shifts in performance in an environmental skill score framework allows us to target the situations in which the greatest improvements may be possible, in terms of forecaster training and/or conceptual models. This work also highlights the essential question that should always be asked in the context of forecast verification: what, exactly, is the baseline standard to which we are comparing forecast performance?
-
Source:Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 102(4), E738-E747.
-
Document Type:
-
Funding:
-
Rights Information:Other
-
Compliance:Submitted
-
Main Document Checksum:urn:sha256:93e3d8162a480af5aa5c1103fd8032602895b95bed8292fc3fd22d45ede926a6
-
File Type:
Supporting Files
-
No Additional Files
More +
Related Documents
-
Personal Author:Link, Jason S. ;Werner, Francisco E....2021 | Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. 78(1): 1-12Description:Many fisheries and marine science organizations are working to determine how to meet their missions in the midst of the COVID-19 outbreak. As such, it...Personal Author:Tam, Jamie C. ;Link, Jason S....2017 | ICES Journal of Marine Science, 74(7): 2040-2052Description:Modern approaches to Ecosystem-Based Management and sustainable use of marine resources must account for the myriad of pressures (interspecies, human ...Personal Author:Link, Jason S. ;Thébaud, Olivier...2017 | ICES Journal of Marine Science, 74(7): 1947-1956Description:The World Ocean presents many opportunities, with the blue economy projected to at least double in the next two decades. However, capitalizing on thes...Personal Author:Thébaud, Olivier ;Link, Jason S....2017 | ICES Journal of Marine Science, 74(7): 1965–1980Description:What do you get when a lawyer, a modeller, an economist, a social scientist and an ecologist talk about the ocean? Besides an interesting conversation...Personal Author:Chase, Randy J. ;Nesbitt, Stephen W....2021 | Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 60(3), 341-359Description:With the launch of the Global Precipitation Measurement Dual-Frequency Precipitation Radar (GPM-DPR) in 2014, renewed interest in retrievals of snowfa...2020 | Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems, 21, e2020GC009360Description:In 2016, temperature recorders were recovered, temperatures were measured, and fluid samples were collected from Vent 1, a high temperature (338°C) h...Personal Author:McFarquhar, Greg M. ;Bretherton, Christopher S....2021 | Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 102(4), E894-E928Description:Weather and climate models are challenged by uncertainties and biases in simulating Southern Ocean (SO) radiative fluxes that trace to a poor understa...2020 | Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 125, e2019JD032237Description:The bulk microphysical properties and number distribution functions (N(D)) of supercooled liquid water (SLW) and ice inside and between ubiquitous gen...2020 | Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 125, e2020JD032465Description:Focusing on conditions of subsidence when low clouds are present, ground-based observations in both the North Atlantic and the Southern Ocean reveal s...Personal Author:Mecikalski, John R. ;Sandmæl, Thea N....2021 | Monthly Weather Review, 149(6), 1725-1746Description:Few studies have assessed combined satellite, lightning, and radar databases to diagnose severe storm potential. The research goal here is to evaluate...Structure of an Atmospheric River Over Australia and the Southern Ocean: II. Microphysical EvolutionCite2020 | Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 125, e2020JD032514Description:An atmospheric river affecting Australia and the Southern Ocean on 28–29 January 2018 during the Southern Ocean Clouds, Radiation, Aerosol Transport...2020 | Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 125, e2020JD032513Description:An atmospheric river (AR) impacting Tasmania, Australia, and the Southern Ocean during the austral summer on 28–29 January 2018 during the Southern ...2020 | Atmosphere 2020, 11(7), 756Description:Retrievals of ice cloud properties require accurate estimates of ice particle mass. Empirical mass–dimensional (m–D) relationships in the form m=a...Stratiform Cloud-Hydrometeor Assimilation for HRRR and RAP Model Short-Range Weather PredictionCitePersonal Author:Benjamin, Stanley G. ;James, Eric P....2021 | Monthly Weather Review, 149(8), 2673-2694Description:Accurate cloud and precipitation forecasts are a fundamental component of short-range data assimilation/model prediction systems such as the NOAA 3-km...Personal Author:Brook, Jordan P. ;Protat, Alain...2021 | Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 60(3), 237-254Description:A spatial mismatch between radar-based hail swaths and surface hail reports is commonly noted in meteorological literature. The discrepancy is partly ...Personal Author:Tuftedal, Kristofer S. ;French, Michael M....2021 | Monthly Weather Review, 149(8), 2539-2557Description:The time preceding supercell tornadogenesis and tornadogenesis “failure” has been studied extensively to identify differing attributes related to ...Personal Author:Jensen, Anders A. ;Pinto, James O....2021 | Monthly Weather Review, 149(5), 1459-1480Description:Uncrewed aircraft system (UAS) observations collected during the 2018 Lower Atmospheric Process Studies at Elevation—a Remotely Piloted Aircraft Tea...Personal Author:Murphy, Amanda M. ;Ryzhkov, Alexander...2020 | Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, 37(9), 1623-1642Description:A novel way to process polarimetric radar data collected via plan position indicator (PPI) scans and display those data in a time–height format is i...Personal Author:Flournoy, Matthew D. ;Coniglio, Michael C....2021 | Weather and Forecasting, 36(3), 737-755Description:Although environmental controls on bulk supercell potential and hazards have been studied extensively, relationships between environmental conditions ...Personal Author:Kuster, Charles M. ;Schuur, Terry J....2020 | Weather and Forecasting, 35(6), 2507-2522Description:Research has shown that dual-polarization (dual-pol) data currently available to National Weather Service forecasters could provide important informat...
More +
You May Also Like
2021 | Monthly Weather Review, 149(4), 901-919
Description:
This study presents an experimental model for Seasonal Probabilistic Outlook for Tornadoes (SPOTter) in the contiguous United States for March, April,...
Personal Author:
Adams-Selin, Rebecca D. ;
Clark, Adam J.
...
2019 | Weather and Forecasting, 34(1), 61-79
Description:
Four different versions of the HAILCAST hail model have been tested as part of the 2014–16 NOAA Hazardous Weather Testbed (HWT) Spring Forecasting E...
Checkout today's featured content at repository.library.noaa.gov