{"Bibliographic":{"Title":"Studies to evaluate the effectiveness of extended-length screens at Little Goose Dam, 1994","Authors":"","Publication date":"1995","Publisher":""},"Administrative":{"Date created":"08-16-2023","Language":"English","Rights":"CC 0","Size":"0000036619"},"Pages":["e CC\nof extended-length screens\nat Little Goose Dam,\nCZES\n1994\ns\nby\nCoastal Zone and\nMichael H. Gessel, Benjamin P. Sandford,\nEstuarine Studies\nand Douglas B. Dey\nDivision\nNorthwest Fisheries\nApril 1995\nScience Center\nNational Marine\nFisheries Service\nSeattle, Washington\nLibrary\nNorthwest\nNOAA\n2725\nSesti","SHI53\nNWFSC097\nL7G3\nSTUDIES TO EVALUATE THE EFFECTIVENESS\nOF EXTENDED-LENGTH SCREENS AT LITTLE GOOSE DAM, 1994\nSH\n153\n,L7\nby\nG3\nMichael H. Gessel\nBenjamin P. Sandford\n1994\nand\nDouglas B. Dey\nLibrary\nNorthwest & Alaska Fisheries Center\nNOAA, National Marine Fisheries Service\n2725 Montlake Boulevard, E.\nSeattle, WA 98112\nAnnual Report of Research\nFunded by\nU.S. Army Corps of Engineers\nWalla Walla District\nDelivery Order E86920164\nand\nCoastal Zone and Estuarine Studies Division\nNorthwest Fisheries Science Center\nNational Marine Fisheries Service\nNational Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration\n2725 Montlake Boulevard East\nSeattle, Washington 98112-2097\nApril 1995","CONTENTS\nPage\nINTRODUCTION\n1\nOBJECTIVE 1: FISH GUIDANCE EFFICIENCY OF THE\nEXTENDED-LENGTH SUBMERSIBLE BAR SCREEN\n3\nApproach\n3\nResults and Discussion\n6\nFish Guidance Efficiency\n6\nOBJECTIVE 2: JUVENILE SALMONID DESCALING\n9\nApproach\n9\nResults and Discussion\n11\nCONCLUSIONS\n11\nACKNOWLEDGMENTS\n12\nREFERENCES\n13\nAPPENDIX A\n14\nAPPENDIX B\n29","INTRODUCTION\nSubmersible traveling screens (STSs) have become an integral\npart of the bypass systems for juvenile salmonids (Oncorhynchus\nspp.) at hydroelectric dams on the Snake and Columbia Rivers.\nStudies to evaluate these screens began at Little Goose and Lower\nGranite Dams during the 1970s and continued through the 1980s.\nFish guidance efficiency (FGE) for yearling chinook salmon (O.\ntshawytscha) and steelhead (0. mykiss) generally has ranged\nbetween 50 and 80%.\nIn 1987, in an effort to provide more consistently high\nguidance levels, the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) and\nthe U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (COE) conducted research at\nLower Granite Dam to test the concept of a longer STS. This new\nguidance concept resulted from engineering studies and hydraulic\nmodel tests conducted by the COE and was tested by placing one\nfixed bar screen (FBS) in one fish screen slot (located upstream\nof the bulkhead slot where the STS is placed) . The FBS provided\nan additional guidance surface, which, in conjunction with the\nSTS was designed to simulate a one-piece extended-length guidance\ndevice. The STS/FBS combination approximately doubled the length\n(to 12.2 m [40 feet] ) of the guiding surface. Results of these\ntests indicated that the STS/FBS combination could improve\nguidance from 51 to 66% for yearling chinook salmon and from 74\nto 82% for steelhead. In 1989, the STS/FBS combination was\ninstalled in all three slots of a turbine intake with 18.8-m (62 -\nft) raised operating gates. Significant increases in FGE were\nmeasured for both yearling chinook salmon and steelhead, with","2\nweighted mean FGES of 66 and 83%, respectively, compared to 57\nand 77% with only an STS and raised operating gate.\nDescaling of fish recovered from gatewells in slots without\nguidance devices was 3% or less. Descaling of guided yearling\nchinook salmon during FGE tests was 2.5 and 4.7% for control and\ntreatment conditions, respectively.\nResults from the Lower Granite Dam studies and continued\nefforts in hydraulic modeling led to the design of two types of\nextended-length screens. During the 1991 juvenile salmonid\noutmigration, NMFS tested extended-length submersible traveling\nscreens (ESTSs) and extended-length submersible bar screens\n(ESBSs) at McNary Dam on the Columbia River. Each of these\nextended-length screens, which are approximately twice as long as\nan STS, guided nearly 80% of the yearling chinook salmon and over\n50% of the subyearling chinook salmon, with no significant\ndifference between devices (Brege et al. 1992) Extended-length\nscreen tests continued from 1992 to 1994 at McNary Dam and were\ninitiated at The Dalles and Little Goose Dams in 1993.\nAt Little Goose Dam in 1993, the results of prototype tests\nof ESTSs and ESBSs with different overall porosities (22, 25, and\n28%), although somewhat limited by the number of tests (10\nreplicates) indicated that FGE was more than 80% for both the\nESTS and ESBS with yearling chinook salmon (Gessel et al. 1994) .\nDescaling of yearling chinook salmon was 7, 9, and 12% for the\nSTS, ESBS, and ESTS, respectively. Also, no obvious differences\nin descaling were found among the different porosity ESBSs.","3\nThis report covers the continued evaluation of extended-\nlength devices during the 1994 smolt outmigration at Little Goose\nDam. Specific research objectives for 1994 were\n1)\nDetermine the FGE of different porosity ESBSs (25 and 28%)\nduring the juvenile salmonid outmigration.\n2)\nDetermine the effect of these extended-length screens on\ndescaling of juvenile salmonids.\nOBJECTIVE 1: FISH GUIDANCE EFFICIENCY OF THE EXTENDED-LENGTH\nSUBMERSIBLE BAR SCREEN\nApproach\nMethods for determining FGE were similar to those used in\nprevious extended-length screen studies at McNary and Little\nGoose Dams (Brege et al. 1992, McComas et al. 1993, Gessel et al.\n1994) . To evaluate their performance under different flow\nconditions, ESBSs (Fig. 1) were tested in Slots 4B and 5A. An\nSTS was used in Slot 3B as a descaling control. Extended-length\nscreens were also placed in the remaining slots of Turbine\nUnits 4 and 5 to maintain uniform flows within each test unit.\nInitial placement of screens for 1994 FGE testing was as follows:\nTurbine\nScreen\nunit/slot\ntype\nPorosity\n3B\nSTS\n48%\n4A\nESTS\n28%\n4B\nESBS\n25%\n4C\nESTS\n25%\n5A\nESBS\n28%\n5B\nESTS\n25%\n5C\nESBS\n25%","4\nThe support structure for the extended-length screens\nextended to the floor of the turbine intake; therefore, the fyke-\nnet frame was placed in the downstream or operating-gate slot\n(Fig. 1) . A full complement of fyke nets (three columns of eight\nrows) with cod ends was used in the two extended-length screen\ntest slots to collect unguided fish. Because only a few fish\nwere caught in the smaller nets of Level 8, the catch totals\nreported for Level 7 include fish caught in Levels 7 and 8.\nFyke-net catch by net column with extended-length screens was\nanalyzed by McComas et al. (1994) .\nAll test and control slots (see page 3) contained modified\nbalanced-flow vertical barrier screens that separated the\ngatewell (bulkhead slot) from the operating-gate slot and\nconfined guided fish to the gatewell (Fig. 1) A solid plate\n(1.3-m wide) was added to the bottom panel of the vertical\nbarrier screens to distribute flow entering the gatewell more\nevenly.\nAll FGE test screens were operated at the standard elevation\nand screen angle was 55° throughout the tests. Operating gates\nwere either fully raised or removed (Fig. 1) .\nWater flows into test turbine units were maintained at\napproximately 19,700 cfs¹ for FGE tests. This corresponded to a\nscreen-approach velocity of around 2.5 fps with turbine power\n1\nTo approximate the flow conditions near the guidance device under\nnormal operating conditions (no net frame in place), it was necessary\nto increase the total flow into the turbine unit during FGE testing.\nThis compensated for the flow reduction caused by the fyke-net frame\nand the full complement of fyke nets, and the head loss associated\nwith extended-length screens.","5\nLittle Goose Dam cross section\n1994 Fyke-net layout\nLevel\nGatewell\n1\n(bulkhead slot)\nJuvenile fish\n2\nbypass flume\n3\nOperating gate\n(raised position)\n4\nGate slot\n5\nVertical barrier\nscreen\n6\n7\n8\nFLOW\nExtended-length\nFyke\nscreen\nnets\nFigure 1. .\nCross section of turbine intake with extended-length - screen and\nfyke nets at Little Goose Dam, 1994.","6\nloads of about 135 MW. For descaling tests conducted without\nfyke nets in the turbine intake, unit loading was 18,300 cfs.\nGatewell dipbasket catches provided the number of guided\nfish while the fyke-net catch gave the number of unguided fish.\nFish guidance efficiency for each species was calculated as the\ngatewell catch divided by the total number of fish (by species)\nentering the turbine intake.\nGW\nFGE =\n100%\nX\n(GW + FN)\nGW = gatewell catch\nFN = fyke-net catch\nTests began about 2000 h and generally lasted from 1 to\n3 hours. At the end of each test, the turbine unit was shut\ndown, the fyke-net frame was raised, and the catch was removed\nfrom each net and placed in a separate container. Both guided\nand unguided fish were counted, by species, and the gatewell\ncatch was examined for descaling.\nMean FGE percentages for yearling chinook salmon and\nsteelhead were statistically analyzed with paired t-tests.\nSignificance was established at a = 0.05.\nResults and Discussion\nFish Guidance Efficiency\nConstraints resulting from the listing of Snake River\nsockeye (O. nerka) and spring/summer chinook salmon influenced\nthe FGE evaluation since we were limited by the number of these\nfish we could handle. As in 1993, we were unable to conduct the","7\ndesired 20 FGE tests during the spring outmigration. Fish\nguidance efficiency tests to compare a 25% porosity ESBS in\nSlot 4B and a 28% porosity ESBS in Slot 5A were conducted from\n28 April to 9 May (10 tests) . Daily fish collections for the FGE\ntests are listed in Appendix Table A1 and the statistical\nanalyses for yearling chinook salmon and steelhead are summarized\nin Appendix Table B1. Mean FGES for the 25 and 28% ESBSs (77 and\n75%, respectively, for yearling chinook salmon) were not\nsignificantly different (Fig. 2) . For steelhead, mean FGE was\nsignificantly higher for the ESBS in Slot 4B with 25% porosity\nthan for the ESBS in Slot 5A with 28% porosity (90 and 86%,\nrespectively) .\nIn addition to the comparison between screen types, we also\nattempted to determine if there was a difference in FGE between\nwild and hatchery smolts. Unfortunately, because of their\nphysical similarities, the presence of some hatchery fish that\nwere not fin clipped, and confusion over how hatchery fish were\nto be clipped, it was not possible to consistently separate wild\nand hatchery yearling chinook salmon during either the 1993 or\n1994 outmigration. It was possible, however, to separate wild\nand hatchery steelhead, but since steelhead were not our target\nspecies, we often ended our nightly FGE tests with relatively low\nnumbers of these fish. During the 1993 outmigration, FGE was 90\nand 89% for wild and hatchery steelhead, respectively. In 1994,\nwe were unable to combine FGE data because there was a\nstatistically significant difference between the two ESBSs. Fish","8\nYearling Chinook Salmon\n28% ESBS\n25% ESBS\nFGE (%)\n100\n80\n60\n40\n20\n0\n28\n29\n30\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n9\nApril - May\nSteelhead\n28% ESBS\n25% ESBS\nFGE (%)\n100\n80\n60\n40\n20\n0\n28\n29\n30\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n9\nApril - May\nFigure 2 . Fish guidance efficiency (FGE) for yearling chinook\nsalmon and steelhead at Little Goose Dam, 1994\n(ESBS = extended - length submersible bar screen)\n.","9\nguidance efficiency was 92 and 90% with the 25% porosity ESBS in\nSlot 4B for wild and hatchery steelhead, respectively. In Slot 5A\nwith the 28% porosity ESBS, FGE was 82 and 87% for wild and\nhatchery steelhead, respectively. Only tests from either year\nwith a minimum of 60 fish (30 wild and 30 hatchery) were used to\ndetermine these percentages. The low numbers of both test fish\nand replicates precluded meaningful statistical comparisons, but\nthese results suggested that any difference in guidance between\nhatchery and wild fish was probably small. Appendix Table A2\nsummarizes daily collection totals for hatchery and wild yearling\nchinook salmon and steelhead at Little Goose Dam in 1994.\nOBJECTIVE 2: JUVENILE SALMONID DESCALING\nApproach\nThe external condition of all juvenile salmonids collected\nin the gatewells was evaluated using standard Fish Transportation\nOversight Team descaling criteria (Ceballos et al. 1992)\n.\nDescaling data were collected from 24 April to 27 May Test\nconditions monitored for descaling are detailed below.\nTest\nPorosity\nNumber\ncondition\nSlot\n(%)\nScreen\nTest days\nof tests\n1\n3B\nSTS\n48\n25 Apr-27 May\n31\n2\n4A\nESTS\n28\n25 Apr-12 May\n12\n3\n4A\nESBS\n25\n13-27 - May\n15\n4\n4B\nESBS\n25\n28 Apr-27 May\n20\n5\n5A\nESBS\n28\n24 Apr-27 May\n32\n6\n5B\nESBS\n25\n24 Apr\n1","10\nStatistical analyses used for the various combinations of\ntest conditions (designated above) were as follows.\nAnalysis\nConditions tested\nStatistical test\n1\n1 and 5 (no steelhead)\nPaired t-test\n2\n1, 2, and 5 (test dates\nBlock ANOVA\n25 Apr-12 May)\n(steelhead) ANOVA\n3\n1, 3, and 5 (test dates 13-27 May)\nBlock ANOVA\n4\n1, (3 + 4) , and 5\nANOVA\nNote that Conditions 1 and 5 were tested together in all\nanalyses and that Conditions 1, 3, and 5 were tested in two\nanalyses. This was due to the time constraints on Conditions 2,\n3, and 4. The analyses attempted to compare conditions only over\nappropriate date ranges to maximize use of blocking by day,\nensure balanced sample sizes between conditions, and remove\npossible seasonal confounding. Also, Conditions 3 and 4 were\nidentical except for the slot used, SO Analysis 3 tested a 25%\nESBS in Slot 4A, while Analysis 4 tested a 25% ESBS in Slots 4A\nand 4B. Conclusions for any comparison were based on the\nanalysis which was most appropriate and precise. Note also that\nAnalysis 1 was not repeated for steelhead. This was due to\nmissing dates (small daily sample sizes) for some steelhead\ndescaling data. Pairing would not have been appropriate and\nAnalysis 1 would have been inferior to (i.e., a subset of)\nAnalysis 5. Daily samples of less than 30 total fish were pooled\nwith the subsequent day (3 days were pooled once) .","11\nResults and Discussion\nThere were no significant differences among mean descaling\npercentages for either yearling chinook salmon or steelhead in\nany of the analyses (Appendix Tables A3 and B2-B6). This was due\nto small actual differences rather than high variability or\ninsufficient sample sizes. Yearling chinook salmon average\ndescaling was 7.1, 8.2, and 7.0%, respectively, for the FGE tests\n(Slot 4B with a 25% porosity ESBS and Slot 5A with a 28% porosity\nESBS) and the control (Slot 3B with an STS). Steelhead descaling\nfor the FGE tests was 4.8, 5.8, and 4.7%, respectively. Mean\ndescaling with the 28% porosity ESTS tested in Slot 4A was 9.4%\nfor yearling chinook salmon and 2.9% for steelhead (small sample\nsizes)\nCONCLUSIONS\n1) For yearling chinook salmon, FGE averaged 77% for the 25%\nporosity extended-length bar screen and 75% for the 28%\nporosity extended-length bar screen. The difference\nwas not statistically significant.\n2) During FGE tests, yearling chinook salmon descaling averaged\n7.1, 8.2, and 7.0% for the 25% porosity extended-length bar\nscreen, the 28% porosity extended-length bar screen, and a\nstandard-length traveling screen, respectively. The\ndifferences were not statistically significant.","12\n3) For steelhead, FGE averaged 90% for the 25% porosity extended- -\nlength bar screen and 86% for the 28% porosity extended-length\nbar screen. The statistical evidence for a significant\ndifference was present but not strong (P = 0.035) .\n4) During FGE tests, steelhead descaling averaged 4.8, 5.8, and\n4.7% for the 25% porosity extended-length bar screen, the 28%\nporosity extended-length bar screen, and a standard-length\ntraveling screen, respectively. The differences were not\nstatistically significant.\nACKNOWLEDGMENTS\nWe express our appreciation to all of the Corps of Engineers\npersonnel at Little Goose Dam for their assistance and\ncooperation in this study. The fish screen maintenance crew,\nsupervised by Ken Weeks, and the Control Room Operators were\nparticularly supportive.","13\nREFERENCES\nBrege, D. A. , S. J. Grabowski, W. D. Muir, S. R. Hirtzel,\nS. J. Mazur, and B. P. Sandford. 1992. Studies to\ndetermine the effectiveness of extended traveling screens\nand extended bar screens at McNary Dam, 1991. Report to\nU.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Contract E86-91-0060, 50 p.\nplus Appendices. (Available from Northwest Fisheries\nScience Center, 2725 Montlake Blvd. E. Seattle, WA\n98112-2097.)\nCeballos, J. R. , S. W. Pettit, and J. L. McKern. 1992. Fish\nTransportation Oversight Team. Annual Report FY - 1991.\nTransportation operations on the Snake and Columbia Rivers.\nU.S. Dep. Commer., NOAA Tech. Memo. NMFS F/NWR-29. 77 p.\nplus Appendix. (Available from Environmental and Technical\nServices Division, 525 N. E. Oregon St. , Suite 500, Portland,\nOR 97232-2737.)\nGessel, M. H. B. P. Sandford, and D. B. Dey. 1994. Studies to\nevaluate the effectiveness of extended-length screens at\nLittle Goose Dam, 1993. Report to U.S. Army Corps of\nEngineers, Contract E86920164, 18 p. plus Appendices.\n(Available from Northwest Fisheries Science Center,\n2725 Montlake Blvd. E., Seattle, WA 98112-2097.)\nMcComas, R. L. D. A. Brege, W. D. Muir, B. P. Sandford, and\nD. B. Dey. 1993. Studies to determine the effectiveness of\nextended-length submersible bar screens at McNary Dam, 1992.\nReport to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Contract E86-91-\n0060, 85 p. plus Appendices. (Available from Northwest\nFisheries Science Center, 2725 Montlake Blvd. E. , Seattle,\nWA 98112-2097.)\nMcComas, R. L. , B. P. Sandford, and D. B. Dey. 1994. Studies to\nevaluate the effectiveness of extended-length screens at\nMcNary Dam, 1993. Report to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers,\nContract E86-91-0060, 85 p. plus Appendices. (Available\nfrom Northwest Fisheries Science Center, 2725 Montlake Blvd.\nE. , Seattle, WA 98112-2097.)","14\nAPPENDIX A\nData Tables","15\nAppendix Table A1\nNumbers of fish caught in individual\nreplicates of fish guidance efficiency\ntests at Little Goose Dam, 1994.\n28 April (4B, 25% ESBS) a\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nTotb\nL\nC\nR\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 2\n6\n9\n1\n8\n9\n3\nLevel 3\n4\n9\n13\n1\n4\n5\nLevel 4\n3\n3\n9\n15\n2\n2\nLevel 5\n3\n3\n2\n8\n1\n1\n1\n3\nLevel 6\n5\n5\n1\n1\n1\n3\nLevel 7c\n1\n1\n1\n1\n2\nNet total 17\n6\n29\n52\n3\n7\n17\n27\nGatewell\n295\n200\nTotal\n347\n227\nFGE (%)\n85\n88\n28 April (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n4\n5\n1\n4\n9\n2\n3\nLevel 3\n7 1\n8\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 4\n1\n6\n2\n6\n14\n3\n5\n3\n11\n1\nLevel 5\n7\n7\n9\n23\n3\n1\n4\n8\nLevel 6\n2\n2\n4\n2\n1\n3\nLevel 7\nNet total\n25\n13\n21\n59\n9\n9\n11\n29\n1\n1\nGatewell\n210\n151\n0\n1\nTotal\n269\n180\nFGE (%)\n78\n84\na Test date (Test slot, perforated plate porosity, and guidance\ndevice type: ESBS = extended-length bar screen) .\nRefers to fyke-net column: L = left, C = center, R = right,\nTot = total catch for net level.\nIncludes data for Levels 7 and 8.","16\nAppendix Table A1.\nContinued.\n29 April (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL C R\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n4\n4\n2\n2\nLevel 2\n3\n1\n4\n8\n1\n3\n4\nLevel 3\n1\n11\n12\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n3\n5\n7\n15\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 5\n3\n3\n5\n11\nLevel 6\n2\n1\n2\n5\nLevel 7\n1\n1\n1\n1\nNet total\n13\n10\n33\n56\n1\n3\n6\n10\nGatewell\n193\n95\nTotal\n249\n105\nFGE (%)\n78\n91\n29 April (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 2\n4\n3\n4\n11\n2\n3\n1\n6\nLevel 3\n7\n1\n2\n10\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n5\n4\n5\n14\n1\n1\nLevel 5\n5\n3\n5\n13\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 6\n1\n3\n4\n8\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 7\n1\n1\n1\n1\nNet total 23\n14\n22\n59\n3\n6\n5\n14\nGatewell\n200\n131\nTotal\n259\n145\nFGE (%)\n77\n90","17\nAppendix Table A1\nContinued.\n30 April (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n1\n2\n3\n1\n1\nLevel 3\n2\n2\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n5\n1\n3\n9\n3\n3\n6\nLevel 5\n6\n5\n11\n1\n1\nLevel 6\n1\n3\n4\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 7\nNet total\n7\n10\n13\n30\n2\n5\n4\n11\nGatewell\n203\n97\nTotal\n233\n108\nFGE (%)\n87\n90\n30 April (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n2\n2\nLevel 2\n1\n2\n3\n1\n1\nLevel 3\n2\n2\n2\n6\n2\n3\n5\nLevel 4\n2\n1\n2\n5\n1\n1\nLevel 5\n3\n2\n7\n12\n1\n3\n4\nLevel 6\n3\n3\n6\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 7\n1\n4\n5\nNet total\n9\n8\n22\n39\n2\n4\n8\n14\nGatewell\n121\n77\nTotal\n160\n91\nFGE (%)\n76\n85","18\nAppendix Table A1.--Continued.\n1 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n3\n4\nLevel 2\n2\n2\n1\n5\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 3\n2\n1\n3\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n3\n1\n5\n9\n2\n1\n3\nLevel 5\n6\n6\n6\n18\n4\n4\nLevel 6\n2\n1\n2\n5\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 7\n1\n1\nNet total\n16\n10\n18\n44\n4\n4\n6\n14\nGatewell\n155\n153\nTotal\n199\n167\nFGE (%)\n78\n92\n1 May (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n2\n2\n4\n1\n2\n1\n4\nLevel 3\n2\n1\n2\n5\n2\n1\n3\nLevel 4\n2\n3\n3\n8\n2\n3\n5\nLevel 5\n6\n2\n4\n12\n3\n2\n5\nLevel 6\n1\n2\n3\n2\n2\n4\nLevel 7\n1\n1\n1\n1\nNet total\n14\n6\n14\n34\n8\n9\n5\n22\nGatewell\n140\n164\nTotal\n174\n186\nFGE (%)\n81\n88","19\nAppendix Table A1\nContinued.\n2 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nLevel 1\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 2\n2\n2\n7\n11\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 3\n5\n5\n2\n2\nLevel 4\n2\n6\n5\n13\nLevel 5\n2\n1\n10\n13\n2\n2\nLevel 6\n1\n1\n2\n4\n2\n2\nLevel 7\nNet total\n8\n10\n31\n49\n1\n7\n8\nGatewell\n257\n144\nTotal\n306\n152\nFGE (%)\n84\n95\n2 May ( (5A, 28% ESBS)\nSteelhead\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSockeye\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nLevel 1\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n3\n1\n1\n5\n1\n1\nLevel 3\n1\n1\n3\n5\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n3\n5\n3\n11\n6\n1\n7\nLevel 5\n1\n9\n3\n13\n6\n2\n2\n10\nLevel 6\n2\n1\n7\n10\n2\n3\n1\n6\nLevel 7\n1\n1\nNet total\n25\n10\n17\n19\n46\n15\n7\n3\nGatewell\n179\n131\nTotal\n225\n156\nFGE (%)\n80\n84","20\nAppendix Table A1 .--Continued.\n3 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 2\n5\n5\n10\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 3\n4\n3\n8\n15\n1\n1\n1\n3\nLevel 4\n5\n5\n6\n16\n2\n1\n1\n4\nLevel 5\n8\n7\n11\n26\n3\n3\nLevel 6\n2\n1\n7\n10\n1\n2\n2\n5\nLevel 7\n1\n1\nNet total\n25\n16\n38\n79\n5\n5\n10\n20\nGatewell\n241\n120\nTotal\n320\n140\nFGE (%)\n75\n86\n3 May (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n1\n6\n7\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 3\n2\n1\n6\n9\n1\n3\n4\nLevel 4\n4\n3\n4\n11\n3\n2\n5\nLevel 5\n4\n5\n13\n22\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 6\n2\n4\n6\n1\n1\n4\n6\nLevel 7\n2\n2\n1\n1\nNet total 13\n9\n36\n58\n7\n1\n12\n20\nGatewell\n198\n123\nTotal\n256\n143\nFGE (%)\n77\n86","21\nAppendix Table A1\nContinued.\n4 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n7\n7\nLevel 2\n3\n1\n2\n6\n1\n1\n1\n3\nLevel 3\n8\n4\n8\n20\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n9\n1\n4\n14\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 5\n7\n11\n9\n27\n3\n1\n4\nLevel 6\n3\n4\n4\n11\n1\n1\nLevel 7\n1\n1\n2\nNet total 30\n22\n35\n87\n2\n5\n4\n11\n0\nGatewell\n290\n166\n1\nTotal\n377\n177\n1\nFGE (%)\n77\n94\n4 May (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n2\n1\n1\n4\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 2\n4\n3\n2\n9\n2\n1\n2\n5\nLevel 3\n4\n3\n10\n17\n7\n7\nLevel 4\n4\n9\n9\n22\n1\n1\n2\n4\nLevel 5\n7\n6\n16\n29\n3\n2\n2\n7\nLevel 6\n1\n2\n7\n10\n1\n1\nLevel 7\n1\n4\n5\n1\n1\n2\nNet total 22\n25\n49\n96\n8\n5\n15\n28\nGatewell\n305\n139\nTotal\n411\n167\nFGE (%)\n74\n83","22\nAppendix Table A1\nContinued.\n5 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n2\n2\nLevel 2\n2\n1\n5\n8\nLevel 3\n1\n1\n4\n6\n1\n1\n3\n5\nLevel 4\n5\n9\n8\n22\n1\n2\n1\n4\nLevel 5\n8\n20\n8\n36\n1\n4\n1\n6\nLevel 6\n4\n8\n5\n17\n2\n2\nLevel 7\n1\n3\n1\n5\n1\n1\nNet total\n21\n42\n33\n96\n4\n7\n7\n18\n0\nGatewell\n278\n164\n4\nTotal\n374\n182\n4\nFGE (%)\n74\n90\n5 May (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL C R\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\nLevel 2\n8\n4\n6\n18\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 3\n2\n7\n6\n15\n1\n1\n2\n4\nLevel 4\n7\n8\n8\n23\n1\n2\n1\n4\nLevel 5\n12\n12\n10\n34\n2\n2\nLevel 6\n2\n8\n6\n16\n1\n1\n2\n2\nLevel 7\n2\n2\n1\n1\nNet total 31\n39\n38\n108\n5\n4\n5\n14\n2\n2\nGatewell\n260\n152\n3\nTotal\n368\n166\n5\nFGE (%)\n71\n92\n60","23\nAppendix Table A1.\nContinued.\n6 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC R Tot\nLevel 1\n3\n1\n4\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n2\n5\n7\n1\n1\nLevel 3\n3\n1\n5\n9\n1\n1\nLevel 4\n8\n7\n9\n24\n1\n2\n1\n4\nLevel 5\n10\n16\n16\n42\n1\n1\n1\n3\nLevel 6\n4\n6\n10\n2\n2\nLevel 7\n3\n3\nNet total 26\n28\n45\n99\n4\n4\n4\n12\n0\nGatewell\n274\n172\n3\nTotal\n373\n184\n3\nFGE (%)\n74\n94\n6 May (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n3\n3\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 2\n7\n1\n5\n13\n1\n1\n4\n6\nLevel 3\n14\n1\n8\n23\n1\n1\n2\n2\n2\nLevel 4\n13\n21\n6\n40\n1\n2\n1\n4\nLevel 5\n9\n20\n14\n43\n1\n1\n1\n3\nLevel 6\n6\n7\n8\n21\n1\n2\n1\n4\n1\n1\nLevel 7\n1\n7\n8\n1\n1\nNet total 49\n51\n51\n151\n6\n6\n10\n22\n3\n3\nGatewell\n310\n237\n1\nTotal\n461\n259\n4\nFGE (%)\n67\n92","24\nAppendix Table A1.\nContinued.\n9 May (4B, 25% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n1\n1\n2\n2\n1\n1\nLevel 2\n3\n1\n4\n1\n1\nLevel 3\n1\n2\n3\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 4\n1\n3\n4\n1\n1\n2\nLevel 5\n2\n3\n4\n9\n1\n1\nLevel 6\n2\n3\n2\n7\n2\n2\n4\nLevel 7\nNet total\n8\n9\n11\n28\n2\n3\n6\n11\n1\n1\n2\nGatewell\n58\n53\n1\nTotal\n86\n64\n3\nFGE (%)\n67\n83\n9 May (5A, 28% ESBS)\nLocation\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nSockeye\nL C R\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nL\nC\nR\nTot\nLevel 1\n2\n1\n3\nLevel 2\n3\n1\n1\n5\n1\n2\n3\nLevel 3\n1\n2\n3\n4\n1\n5\nLevel 4\n4\n1\n3\n8\n2\n2\n4\nLevel 5\n3\n2\n5\n2\n4\n4\n10\nLevel 6\n2\n2\n4\n2\n2\nLevel 7\n1\n1\n1\n2\n3\nNet total 13\n2\n11\n26\n10\n11\n9\n30\nGatewell\n67\n90\nTotal\n93\n120\nFGE (%)\n72\n75","25\nAppendix Table A2 - - Hatchery and wild yearling chinook salmon and\nsteelhead collected during fish guidance\nefficiency and descaling tests at Little\nGoose Dam, 1994.\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nPercent\nPercent\nWilda\nTotal\nwild\nHatchery Wild Total\nwild\nDate\nHatchery\n24 April\n85\n78\n163\n47.9\n25\n26\n51\n51.0\n25 April\n147\n165\n312\n52.9\n70\n145\n215\n67.4\n26\nApril\n238\n136\n374\n36.4\n69\n33\n102\n32.4\n27 April\n227\n137\n364\n37.6\n33\n46\n79\n58.2\n28 April\n608\n227\n835\n27.2\n187\n237\n424\n55.9\n29 April\n612\n97\n709\n13.7\n208\n71\n279\n25.4\n30 April\n522\n118\n640\n18.4\n122\n90\n212\n42.5\n1 May\n482\n91\n573\n15.9\n314\n59\n373\n15.8\n2 May\n533\n335\n17.3\n91\n624\n14.6\n277\n58\n3 May\n663\n346\n23.4\n137\n800\n17.1\n265\n81\n20.7\n4 May\n744\n155\n899\n17.2\n288\n75\n363\n14.8\n5 May\n791\n139\n930\n14.9\n322\n56\n378\n6 May\n764\n158\n922\n17.1\n407\n44\n451\n9.8\n9 May\n239\n17\n256\n6.6\n268\n19\n287\n6.6\n10 May\n237\n41\n278\n14.7\n501\n45\n546\n8.2\n11 May\n345\n58\n403\n14.4\n123\n9\n132\n6.8\n12 May\n323\n31\n354\n8.8\n217\n27\n244\n11.1\n13 May\n391\n42\n433\n9.7\n287\n8\n295\n2.7\n14 May\n362\n32\n394\n8.1\n664\n55\n719\n7.6\n15 May\n126\n25\n151\n16.6\n358\n45\n403\n11.2\n16 May\n297\n50\n347\n14.4\n683\n53\n736\n7.2\n17 May\n362\n28\n390\n7.2\n83\n10\n93\n10.8\n45\n361\n12.5\n18 May\n508\n75\n583\n12.9\n316\n492\n15.0\n19 May\n533\n72\n605\n11.9\n418\n74\n398\n7.5\n20 May\n664\n105\n769\n13.7\n368\n30\n6.4\n21 May\n622\n140\n762\n18.4\n689\n47\n736\n22 May\n475\n62\n537\n11.5\n517\n19\n536\n3.5\n23 May\n750\n57\n807\n7.1\n271\n53\n324\n16.4\n24 May\n859\n49\n908\n5.4\n363\n98\n461\n21.3\n67\n719\n9.3\n25 May\n231\n35\n266\n13.2\n652\n462\n4.5\n26 May\n515\n50\n565\n8.8\n441\n21\n11.5\n27 May\n565\n108\n673\n16.0\n392\n51\n443\nThe estimated number of wild yearling chinook salmon is based\na\non the assumption that all hatchery fish had either the adipose\nfin clipped or a ventral fin clipped.","26\nAppendix Table A3 - - Descaling data from fish guidance efficiency tests\nconducted at Little Goose Dam, 1994.\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nTest\nTotal\nNumber\nPercent\nTotal\nNumber\nPercent\ndate\ncatch\ndescaled\ndescaled\ncatch\ndescaled\ndescaled\nUnit 3, Slot B (48% STS)\n25 April\n155\n11\n7.1\n13\n0\n0.0\n26 April\n113\n7\n6.2\n16\n1\n6.3\n27 April\n67\n2\n3.0\n5\n0\n0.0\n28 April\n121\n11\n9.1\n10\n0\n0.0\n29 April\n117\n8\n6.8\n12\n1\n8.3\n30 April\n127\n4\n3.2\n4\n0\n0.0\n1 May\n99\n3\n3.0\n15\n1\n6.7\n2 May\n93\n7\n7.5\n27\n1\n3.7\n3 May\n109\n13\n11.9\n47\n1\n2.1\n4 May\n117\n15\n12.8\n19\n0\n0.0\n5 May\n111\n6\n5.4\n11\n2\n18.2\n6 May\n89\n5\n5.6\n8\n0\n0.0\n9 May\n77\n5\n6.5\n103\n4\n3.9\n10 May\n59\n3\n5.1\n142\n2\n1.4\n11 May\n119\n8\n6.7\n81\n4\n4.9\n12 May\n100\n13\n13.0\n82\n3\n3.7\n13\nMay\n118\n9\n7.6\n89\n5\n5.6\n14 May\n69\n13\n18.8\n231\n21\n9.1\n15 May\n67\n5\n7.5\n123\n3\n2.4\n16 May\n68\n3\n4.4\n125\n9\n7.2\n17\nMay\n96\n9\n9.4\n20\n1\n5.0\n18 May\n106\n10\n9.4\n187\n13\n7.0\n5.7\n19 May\n137\n6\n4.4\n157\n9\n20 May\n140\n9\n6.4\n65\n5\n7.7\n21 May\n142\n7\n4.9\n185\n7\n3.8\n22 May\n95\n4\n4.2\n222\n13\n5.9\n23 May\n25\n1\n4.0\n231\n15\n6.5\n24 May\n53\n1\n1.9\n250\n23\n9.2\n25 May\n35\n5\n14.3\n126\n3\n2.4\n26 May\n76\n1\n1.3\n69\n2\n2.9\n27 May\n56\n3\n5.4\n129\n7\n5.4\nUnit 4, Slot A (28% extended-length traveling screen)\n25 April\n105\n11\n10.5\n52\n0\n0.0\n26 April\n199\n13\n6.5\n34\n0\n0.0\n27 April\n227\n15\n6.6\n18\n0\n0.0\n28 April\n98\n11\n11.2\n7\n0\n0.0\n29 April\n84\n4\n4.8\n17\n0\n0.0\n30 April\n120\n5\n4.2\n4\n0\n0.0\n1 May\n101\n8\n7.9\n5\n0\n0.0\n3 May\n115\n10\n8.7\n16\n0\n0.0\n5 May\n77\n8\n10.4\n19\n2\n10.5\n10 May\n79\n12\n15.2\n117\n3\n2.6\n11 May\n113\n19\n16.8\n43\n1\n2.3\n12 May\n96\n9\n9.4\n126\n19\n15.1","27\nAppendix Table A3 -\n-Continued.\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nTest\nTotal\nNumber\nPercent\nTotal\nNumber\nPercent\ndate\ncatch\ndescaled\ndescaled\ncatch\ndescaled\ndescaled\nUnit 4, Slot A (25% extended-length bar screen)\n13 May\n118\n18\n15.3\n129\n9\n7.0\n14 May\n108\n12\n11.1\n238\n25\n10.5\n15 May\n73\n10\n13.7\n169\n18\n10.7\n16 May\n76\n7\n9.2\n203\n12\n5.9\n17 May\n138\n12\n8.7\n47\n5\n10.6\n18\nMay\n146\n13\n8.9\n88\n8\n9.1\n19 May\n142\n9\n6.3\n116\n4\n3.4\n20\nMay\n147\n7\n4.8\n98\n4\n4.1\n21 May\n89\n8\n9.0\n170\n3\n1.8\n22 May\n115\n15\n13.0\n165\n11\n6.7\n23 May\n39\n1\n2.6\n158\n13\n8.2\n24\nMay\n92\n7\n7.6\n226\n15\n6.6\n25 May\n75\n8\n10.7\n282\n15\n5.3\n26 May\n103\n2\n1.9\n149\n15\n10.1\n27 May\n121\n4\n3.3\n93\n7\n7.5\nUnit 4, Slot B (25% extended-length bar screen)\n28 April\n295\n25\n8.5\n200\n8\n4.0\n29 April\n193\n6\n3.1\n95\n3\n3.2\n30 April\n203\n14\n6.9\n97\n2\n2.1\n1 May\n155\n14\n9.0\n153\n7\n4.6\n2 May\n257\n18\n7.0\n144\n7\n4.9\n3 May\n241\n26\n10.8\n120\n3\n2.5\n4 May\n290\n21\n7.2\n166\n8\n4.8\n5 May\n278\n25\n9.0\n164\n7\n4.3\n6 May\n274\n28\n10.2\n172\n17\n9.9\n9 May\n58\n6\n10.3\n53\n2\n3.8\n10 May\n70\n8\n11.4\n118\n10\n8.5\n16 May\n107\n9\n8.4\n201\n10\n5.0\n20 May\n137\n9\n6.6\n100\n4\n4.0\n21 May\n164\n9\n5.5\n152\n10\n6.6\n22 May\n112\n4\n3.6\n136\n5\n3.7\n23 May\n63\n1\n1.6\n213\n12\n5.6\n24 May\n136\n6\n4.4\n191\n9\n4.7\n25 May\n50\n3\n6.0\n119\n2\n1.7\n26 May\n76\n4\n5.3\n78\n4\n5.1\n27\nMay\n104\n8\n7.7\n118\n8\n6.8","28\nAppendix Table A3 - Continued.\nYearling chinook\nSteelhead\nTotal\nNumber\nPercent\nTest\nTotal\nNumber\nPercent\ndescaled\ndescaled\ndate\ncatch\ndescaled\ndescaled\ncatch\nUnit 5, Slot A (28% extended-length bar screen)\n24 April\n56\n2\n3.6\n35\n1\n2.9\n25 April\n1.3\n52\n5\n9.6\n150\n2\n26 April\n71\n3\n4.2\n52\n5\n9.6\n27 April\n56\n70\n4\n5.7\n1\n1.8\n28 April\n4\n2.6\n210\n9\n4.3\n151\n29 April\n200\n10\n5.0\n131\n5\n3.8\n30 April\n77\n2\n2.6\n121\n9\n7.4\n5\n3.0\n1 May\n140\n7\n5.0\n164\n4.6\n2 May\n179\n10\n5.6\n131\n6\n10.6\n123\n8\n6.5\n3 May\n198\n21\n139\n1\n0.7\n4 May\n305\n20\n6.6\n7\n4.6\n5 May\n260\n22\n8.5\n152\n6 May\n310\n28\n9.0\n237\n10\n4.2\n9 May\n67\n7\n10.4\n90\n4\n4.4\n169\n9\n5.3\n10 May\n70\n12\n17.1\n1\n12.5\n11\nMay\n171\n11\n6.4\n8\n6\n16.7\n12\nMay\n158\n15\n9.5\n36\n2\n2.6\n13\nMay\n197\n35\n17.8\n77\n8\n10.7\n14\nMay\n123\n19\n15.4\n75\n10\n9.0\n15\nMay\n146\n12\n8.2\n111\n12\n5.8\n16\nMay\n96\n12\n12.5\n207\n3\n11.5\n17\nMay\n146\n20\n13.7\n26\n1\n1.6\n18\nMay\n149\n15\n10.1\n61\n4.3\n19\nMay\n139\n9\n6.5\n117\n5\n4.5\n20\nMay\n240\n18\n7.5\n44\n2\n2.7\n21\nMay\n184\n9\n4.9\n184\n5\n4.6\n22\nMay\n123\n10\n8.1\n130\n6\n7.5\n23\nMay\n62\n4\n6.5\n106\n8\n8.1\n24\nMay\n106\n3\n2.8\n172\n14\n7.0\n25\nMay\n43\n3\n7.0\n115\n8\n12.3\n26\nMay\n138\n3\n2.2\n73\n9\n27\nMay\n100\n9\n9.0\n86\n6\n7.0","29\nAPPENDIX B\nStatistical Tables","30\nAppendix Table B1.\nYearling chinook salmon and steelhead FGE\n-\ncomparison between a 28% porosity ESBS in\nSlot 5A and a 25% porosity ESBS in Slot 4B;\npaired t-test, means, and standard error\n(SE) .\nSlot\nPorosity\nFGE\nSE\n(%)\n(%)\nYearling Chinook\n5A\n28\n75.0\n1.2\n4B\n25\n77.3\nt- test\nt = 1.30\ndf = 8\np-value = 0.2300\nSteelhead\n5A\n28\n86.3\n0.9\n4B\n25\n89.6\n-test\np-value = 0.0347\nt = 2.54\ndf = 8\nAppendix Table B2\nYearling chinook salmon descaling comparison\nbetween a 28% porosity ESBS in Slot 5A and an\nSTS in Slot 3B ; paired t-test, means, and\nstandard error (SE) .\nSlot\nPorosity\nDescaling\nSE\n(%)\n(%)\n0.5\n5A\n28\n8.3\n3B\n48\n7.0\n-test\ndf = 30\np-value = 0.1012\nt = 1.69","31\nAppendix Table B3\nYearling chinook salmon descaling comparison\nbetween a 28% porosity ESBS in Slot 5A, a 28%\nporosity ESTS in Slot 4A, and an STS in\nSlot 3B; Block ANOVA, means, and standard\nerror (SE) .\nSlot\nScreen\nPorosity\nDescaling\nSE\n(%)\n(%)\n5A\nESBS\n28\n7.8\n0.9\n4A\nESTS\n28\n9.4\n3B\nSTS\n48\n6.7\nANOVA\nSum of\nMean\ndf\np-value\nSource\nF\nsquares\nsquare\nDay\n223.5\n11\n20.3\nTreatment\n42.2\n2\n21.1\n2.27\n0.1270\nError\n204.3\n22\n9.3\nTotal\n469.9\n35\nAppendix Table B4\nSteelhead descaling comparison between a 28%\nporosity ESBS in Slot 5A, a 28% porosity ESTS\nin Slot 4A, and an STS in Slot 3B; ANOVA,\nmeans, and standard errors (SE)\n.\nSlot\nScreen\nPorosity\nDescaling\nSE\n(%)\n(%)\n5A\nESBS\n28\n4.7\n1.0\n4A\nESTS\n28\n2.9\n1.2\n3B\nSTS\n48\n3.8\n1.2\nANOVA\nSum of\nMean\ndf\np-value\nSource\nF\nsquares\nsquare\nTreatment\n20.6\n2\n10.3\n0.74\n0.4873\nError\n418.8\n30\n14.0\nTotal\n439.4\n32","32\n- Yearling chinook salmon and steelhead\nAppendix Table B5\ndescaling comparison between a 28% porosity\nESBS in Slot 5A, a 25% porosity ESBS in\nSlot 4A, and an STS in Slot 3B; Block ANOVA,\nmeans, and standard error (SE)\nSlot Screen\nPorosity\nDescaling\nSE\n(%)\n(%)\nYearling Chinook\n8.8\n0.8\n5A\n28\nESBS\n4A\nESBS\n25\n8.4\n3B\nSTS\n48\n6.4\nANOVA\nSum of\nMean\np-value\ndf\nF\nSource\nsquares\nsquare\nDay\n552.0\n14\n39.4\n14.7\n1.61\n0.2177\nTreatment\n29.4\n2\nError\n255.2\n28\n9.1\nTotal\n836.6\n44\nSteelhead\n6.6\n0.6\n5A\nESBS\n28\n4A\nESBS\n25\n7.1\n5.7\n3B\nSTS\n48\nANOVA\nSum of\nMean\ndf\np-value\nF\nSource\nsquares\nsquare\n14\nDay\n155.8\n11.1\n1.32\n0.2828\nTreatment\n16.1\n2\n8.0\nError\n170.0\n28\n6.1\nTotal\n341.8\n44","33\nAppendix Table B6,\nYearling chinook salmon and steelhead\ndescaling comparison between a 28% porosity\nESBS in Slot 5A, a 25% porosity ESBS in\nSlot 4A and 4B, and an STS in Slot 3B;\nANOVA, means, and standard errors (SE).\nSlot\nPorosity\nScreen\nDescaling\nSE\n(%)\n(%)\nYearling Chinook\n5A\n28\n8.3\nESBS\n0.7\n4\nESBS\n25\n7.7\n0.7\n3B\nSTS\n48\n7.0\n0.6\nANOVA\nSum of\nMean\nSource\ndf\np-value\nF\nsquares\nsquare\nTreatment\n26.1\n2\n13.1\n0.96\n0.3882\nError\n1284.9\n94\n13.7\nTotal\n1311.1\n96\nSteelhead\n5A\nESBS\n28\n5.7\n0.5\n4\nESBS\n25\n5.8\n0.5\n3B\nSTS\n48\n5.0\n0.6\nANOVA\nSum of\nMean\nSource\ndf\nF\np-value\nsquares\nsquare\nTreatment\n10.3\n2\n5.2\n0.62\n0.5412\nError\n719.1\n86\n8.4\nTotal\n729.5\n88"]}